The Connection Between Better Decision-Making and Healthcare Affordability

Professional headshot of a man in a gray blazer over a checkered shirt

Dave Murtaugh

General Manager, Network Services, Claritev

Healthcare organizations and employers are facing a challenge that grows more complex every year: how do you make healthcare more affordable without limiting access to care?

This question sits at the center of nearly every healthcare decision.

Employers want to offer competitive benefits while managing rising costs. Their health plans need to maintain broad access to providers while ensuring financial sustainability. Providers are balancing growing administrative demands with the need to deliver high-quality care. And patients increasingly want healthcare experiences that are as transparent and convenient as those they encounter in other parts of their lives.

The challenge is amplified because most health plan decisions have trade-offs that don’t move all these priorities in the preferred direction.

Understanding the dynamics of network strategy

Most healthcare organizations view affordability and access as opposing forces. Expanding provider choice can increase costs. Tightening cost controls can limit options. The result is a constant balancing act, one that has become more difficult as healthcare spending continues to rise and the system becomes increasingly complex.

While it’s true, every healthcare network, benefit design, and reimbursement strategy involves trade-offs, a strategic, data-driven approach can lead to better decisions.

No network is identical. Each has strengths, limitations, and unique characteristics that vary by market, provider mix, and negotiated arrangements. Yet many organizations still lack the visibility needed to use their network strategy to improve both access and affordability. The reality is that healthcare organizations achieve better outcomes when they understand the specific dynamics of their network and align benefit design accordingly.

Consider laboratory services as an example.

In some markets, independent laboratories can provide the same service at a significantly lower cost than hospital-based facilities. When benefit plans are designed to encourage members to use high-value care settings, organizations can reduce costs without reducing access. Patients benefit from lower out-of-pocket expenses, while employers and health plans gain spend predictability and reduce the risk of future premium pressure. In this example, an employer may offer a reduced co-pay for use of the independent labs.

Organizations that understand where value exists within their healthcare ecosystem are better positioned to create experiences that support both affordability and access.

The goal is to provide information that allows people to make choices that maximize value for patients, employers, and the healthcare system as a whole.

Transparency is only valuable if it leads to action

The healthcare industry has made significant progress in expanding access to pricing information. Yet transparency alone does not solve the affordability problem. Data only creates value when it helps organizations make more informed decisions.

Healthcare leaders today have access to more information than ever before. The challenge is turning that information into practical guidance that helps them understand market dynamics, evaluate trade-offs, and identify opportunities to improve affordability without compromising quality or access.

For example, we are increasingly leveraging public price transparency data as part of our network market analysis. This transforms regulations promoting greater transparency into tangible value. The goal is not to find the lowest price. It is to make decisions that are informed and in sync with the evolving needs of patients and providers. The shift from information to action is where many of the most important opportunities in healthcare now exist.

Organizations can use price transparency data to better understand local market conditions, benchmark pricing, and create more sustainable approaches to managing healthcare costs over time.

Innovating to meet consumer expectations

Healthcare consumers are becoming more active participants in their care decisions.

Patients increasingly expect greater visibility into costs before receiving care. They want to compare options, understand pricing, and make decisions with confidence.

These expectations mirror what consumers experience in nearly every other industry. Whether booking travel, shopping online, or selecting a financial service, people expect transparency and choice. Healthcare must innovate and move in the same direction.

As organizations explore new care models, digital experiences, and alternative payment approaches, there is growing demand for tools and infrastructure that make healthcare decisions easier to navigate. An example of innovation in action can be found in our Vistara Connect app, where a cost estimation tool can help members make faster, more informed decisions. The ability to understand costs upfront, compare options, and reduce uncertainty can help create a more informed and empowered healthcare experience.

Flexibility matters — but so does simplicity

Healthcare organizations serve different populations with different needs. A solution that works well for one employer, health plan, or community may not be the right fit for another. As a result, there is increasing interest in more tailored approaches to network design and benefit strategy.

However, flexibility can introduce its own challenge: complexity. The more customized a healthcare experience becomes, the more important it is to provide clarity for every stakeholder involved. Members need to understand their coverage. Providers need confidence in reimbursement and eligibility processes. Health plans need visibility into performance and outcomes.

The future of healthcare will require both flexibility and simplicity, giving organizations more options while making those options easier to understand and manage.

Clarity in Action 

The path to a more affordable healthcare system will not come from any single innovation or policy change. It will come from the cumulative effect of enabling better decisions every day, across all stakeholders.

Better decision-making benefits health plans, employers, and providers. But most importantly, it benefits patients. Because at the end of every healthcare decision is a person trying to access care without confusion, unexpected costs, or unnecessary complexity.

Pattern

New ideas, proven best practices, and fresh perspectives for the healthcare ecosystem.

  • Better Decisions Start Here: How TPAs Can Turn Insight Into Impact

    Dallas Scrip draws on decades of experience in the TPA and healthcare space to show how actionable insight—not just transparency—drives smarter decisions, lower costs,…

    Read More
  • One Claim, Two Claim, Fast Claim, True Claim: ePA for the Real World

    At ViVE, Claritev’s Vice President of Partnerships and Channel Development, Claritev, Bill Morgan joined a live panel discussion focused on modernizing the prior authorization…

    Read More
  • We’re Bending the Healthcare Cost Curve Toward Savings and Value in Care

    Discover how Claritev is bending the healthcare cost curve by leveraging data analytics, technology, and industry experts to improve care value and combat rising…

    Read More